We taste tested the most popular Easter eggs of 2019 so you don't have to

16 April 2019, 13:16

Easter egg Taste test
We tested all these Easter eggs . Picture: Getty
Alice Dear

By Alice Dear

Not sure what Easter egg to buy this year? Don't worry, we did the leg work for you.

Easter is finally upon us, which means the feasting on chocolate eggs can at last begin.

But whether you're buying for yourself or a loved one, it's so hard to know which eggs are worth the money, and which ones will leave you disappointed.

From Thornton's to Kinder, here's what the taste testers at Heart HQ thought:

Maltesers Buttons Easter Egg £6

Heart's average score: 7.4/10

Maltesers Buttons Easter Egg £6
Maltesers Buttons Easter Egg £6. Picture: Nestle

With a strong score of 7.4, the Maltesers Easter egg is a safe bet and a classic chocolate go-to.

The testers described the taste as "creamy", although also a little "cloggy".

Buy it here.

Thornton’s Marvellous Magnificent Easter Egg £20

Heart's average score: 5.8/10

Thorton’s Marvellous Magnificent Easter Egg £20
Thorton’s Marvellous Magnificent Easter Egg £20. Picture: Thortons

While one of the more expensive eggs, Thornton's Easter egg did not perform as well as we expected.

The taste testers were not blown away, describing the egg as a "bit boring".

The egg however did have some fans, with one taster commenting the chocolate was "a real gem of the taste test".

Buy it here.

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk Freddo Easter egg £1.50

Heart's average score: 6.4/10

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk Freddo Easter egg £1.50
Cadbury’s Dairy Milk Freddo Easter egg £1.50. Picture: Cadbury's

The classic Cadbury's Easter egg divided our chocolate testers.

Some were keen for the iconic taste, branding it "near perfection", while others called the taste "dull".

Buy it here.

Ferrero Rocher Milk Chocolate & Hazelnut Easter Egg £9

Heart's average score: 6.6/10

Ferrero Rocher Milk Chocolate & Hazelnut Easter Egg £9
Ferrero Rocher Milk Chocolate & Hazelnut Easter Egg £9. Picture: Ferrero Rocher

The Ferrero Rocher Easter egg also divided the tasters.

Understandably, some loved the hazelnut egg and set of three Ferrero Rochers that came with it, while others weren't keen on the nutty version of the egg.

Buy it here.

Reese's Chocolate Easter Egg £6

Heart's average score: 4.5/10

Reese's Chocolate Easter Egg £6
Reese's Chocolate Easter Egg £6. Picture: Reese's

Surprisingly, the Reese's Easter egg is in fact not peanut flavoured, but just a simple milk chocolate egg.

Some taste testers were disappointed by the plain chocolate flavour, with one admitting they'd only "buy it for a distant family member".

Buy it here.

Kinder Surprise Easter Egg £5

Heart's average score: 8.2/10

Kinder Surprise Easter Egg £5
Kinder Surprise Easter Egg £5. Picture: Kinder

Kinder's Easter egg not only provides a tasty egg, but a huge toy inside the large egg.

The scores show this egg as one of the favourites, with the classic taste and creamy texture.

Buy it here.

Nestle Smarties Orange Chocolate Egg £8

Heart's average score: 7.1/10

Nestle Smarties Orange Chocolate Egg £8
Nestle Smarties Orange Chocolate Egg £8. Picture: Nestle

Although not a classic Easter egg, the Smarties Orange egg also turned out to be a favourite.

The taste testers described the egg as "orange goodness", and "a real contender".

Buy it here.

Lidl’s Golden Sculpture Egg with Ginsecco £12.99

Heart's average score: 4.5/10

Lidl’s Golden Sculpture Egg with Ginsecco £12.99
Lidl’s Golden Sculpture Egg with Ginsecco £12.99. Picture: Lidl

Lidl's Golden Sculpture Egg with Ginsecco did not score as well as expected.

The taste of the egg was described as a "little boring" and failed to impress the taste testers.

Buy it here.